The Xbox Elite Series 2 is Microsoft’s premium gamepad for the Xbox, crafted to elevate your gaming experience beyond what a standard controller can offer. But SCUF, a renowned name in custom controllers, also delivers high-performance gamepads for Xbox, making the decision of which to buy a bit tricky.
In this comparison, we break down the key design, performance, and feature differences between the Xbox Elite Series 2 and a SCUF controller to help you make an informed decision in this regard. While both are undeniably top-tier, understanding their unique features will ensure you choose the right fit for your needs.
Which SCUF Controllers Compare to the Elite Series 2?
SCUF offers several premium controllers for Xbox, but the SCUF Instinct is the closest competitor to Microsoft’s Elite Series 2, especially in terms of price. Below, we break down their similarities and key differences so you can decide which one best suits your gaming needs.
Similarities - Elite Series 2 vs SCUF Instinct:
- Price: Both controllers are similarly priced, with the Elite Series 2 retailing for $179.99 (£159.99) and the SCUF Instinct costing $169.99 (£169.99). However, the Elite Series 2 is more widely available at other retailers, often found at discounted prices through major outlets like Amazon.
- Back Buttons: Both controllers feature four additional back buttons for advanced inputs. The SCUF Instinct uses more traditional-style buttons, positioned where your fingers naturally rest. The Elite Series 2 features removable metal paddles, similar to gear shifters behind a modern racing wheel.
- Interchangeable Sticks: Both controllers include extra thumbsticks for customization. The Elite Series 2 offers tall, short, and domed stick options, while the SCUF Instinct provides a short concave and a tall domed stick.
- Saveable Profiles: Each controller lets you save up to three custom profiles, allowing quick switching between different setups.
- Connectivity: Both controllers can be used wired or wirelessly via Bluetooth or a USB-C cable.
Differences - Elite Series 2 vs SCUF Instinct:
- Adjustable Triggers: The Elite Series 2 features three levels of trigger stops, letting you adjust trigger sensitivity for quicker reactions. The standard SCUF Instinct doesn't have this.
- Carry Case: The Elite Series 2 includes a carrying case that holds the controller, extra thumbsticks, paddles, and more. The SCUF Instinct does not include a case, meaning you’ll need to purchase one separately.
- Adjustable Stick Tension: The Elite Series 2 allows you to fine-tune thumbstick tension using an included adjustment tool, improving accuracy based on your preference. The SCUF Instinct does not offer adjustable stick tension.
- Grip: The Elite Series 2 features a wraparound rubberized grip, enhancing comfort and control, whereas the SCUF Instinct has a more standard grip, which may not be as premium-feeling.
SCUF does offer an upgraded version of the Instinct—the Instinct Pro—which adds extra features for a more premium experience. However, opting for the Pro model comes at a higher price, retailing for $219.99 (£189.99) if purchased directly from SCUF, making it more expensive than the Elite Series 2 at full price.
That said, the Instinct Pro does come with a few notable upgrades to help justify its higher price tag. It features adjustable triggers, allowing you to switch between a full-range press and a mouse-like click for faster inputs. Additionally, it comes with a wrap-around rubberized grip for improved comfort and control, as well as built-in rumble technology to match the Elite Series 2’s haptic and vibration feedback.
Interestingly, while the Instinct Pro is more expensive through SCUF’s store, the controller is often on sale over at Amazon. Prices can fluctuate, but regular discounts often bring the Instinct Pro closer to the Elite Series 2’s price point, making it a more competitive option if you can find it on sale.
Should You Buy an Xbox Elite Series 2 or SCUF Controller?
While the choice ultimately comes down to personal preference and gaming needs, a direct comparison of features suggests that the Elite Series 2 edges out the SCUF Instinct as the more complete controller.
With adjustable triggers, customizable stick tension, a wrap-around grip, and a premium carry case, the Elite Series 2 simply offers more out of the box. In fact, its feature set is more comparable to the pricier Instinct Pro, making it an even stronger value at its standard price.
That said, if you can find the Instinct Pro at a discount, it becomes a more competitive alternative, especially for those with budget concerns. But at the end of the day, both controllers are excellent choices within the premium controller market, where even the smallest differences can impact performance.
Final Thoughts
No matter which controller you choose, both the Xbox Elite Series 2 and SCUF Instinct offer premium features designed to enhance your gaming experience. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference and playstyle, so pick the one that best fits your needs and take your gameplay to the next level.